Be sure to read our Shipping Policies before you place an order!
We reserve the right to cancel and refund any order if we
deem the temperature too warm to ship safely.
We require a minimum order of $20 (before shipping). Free shipping on orders over $150.00!*
The cheeses in the Traditional, Organic, Grass-fed, and Goat categories are produced in the heart of Ohio Amish country by one of the last farmer-owned dairy co-ops in the US. The milk comes from the farms of Amish families who generally keep 10–20 cows and refrain from using hormones and prophylactic antibiotics on their herds. The milk is delivered fresh daily, where it is transformed into delicious natural cheeses by traditional cheese-making methods, yielding a natural, high-quality product. The Amish cheese is moist, pungent, and flavorful. The cheese is pulled directly from the aging house and hand-cut just before your order is shipped. You will not likely find cheese like this at a more family-friendly price.