We offer a variety of cheeses that aren't part of the Amish community, but are still incredibly delicious. From tangy blue cheese to sliced American, these cheeses are sure to satisfy your cheese cravings. Indulge and enjoy!


Products 1-5 of 5
Show
American Cheese american cheese, processed cheese, amish cheese blend, cheese blend, blended cheese, amish american cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
(6)
Price: $4.67

Price: $4.67
Availability: In Stock
Great Lakes

American cheese is like a superhero in the cheese world, always ready to save the day with its creamy, melty powers! Perfect for topping burgers or making gooey grilled cheeses, this processed blend of Colby and Cheddar is a mild-mannered hero that's always in the mood for adventure. Whether you're cooking up a storm or just snacking on something delicious, American cheese is the perfect sidekick for any cheese lover. Note: Contains soy ingredients.

Blue Cheese 1lb blue cheese, blue, about blue cheese, amish blue cheese, natural amish blue cheese, what is blue cheese, where to find amish cheese, online amish cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
(3)
Price: $13.91

Price: $13.91
Availability: In Stock
Rosenborg-Castello

Blue Cheese Lovers Rejoice! This Danish delicacy packs a punch with its full-strength flavor that sets it apart from the rest. It's made using homogenized milk, giving it a sharp and slightly salty "blue bite." The cheese is crumbly with veins and pockets of blue mold, adding both texture and taste to your next dish. Toss it in salads, crumble it over grilled meats, blend it into spreads and dips, or let it be the star of the show on a cheese platter. Don't miss out on this classic blue cheese...

Danish Havarti 1lb havarti, amish havarti, danish cheese, danish, danish havarti, amish cheese online, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
(2)
Price: $13.08

Price: $13.08
Availability: In Stock
Castello

Say cheese! 🧀 Introducing the creamy, dreamy Havarti. This semi-soft Danish delight is the life of the party, perfect for slicing, grilling, or melting. With a smooth, rindless texture and a sunny yellow hue, Havarti is the interior-ripened cheese that's always ready to have a good time! 😋

Grated Parmesan grated, parmesan, grated parmesan, grated parmesan amish cheese, grated parmesan cheese, amish parmesan cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
(1)
Price: $8.38

Price: $8.38
Availability: In Stock

Say hello to the mighty, ready-to-use dry grated Parmesan. No more grating, no more fuss! Just open the bag and let the fun begin. Sprinkle it on your pasta, soups, salads, or anything that needs a cheesy kick. Ingredients: Pasteurized Part-skim Milk, Salt, less than 2% of Enzymes, Cheese Culture, Cellulose Powder to Prevent Caking, Potassium Sorbate to Protect Flavor

Muenster 1lb about muenster cheese, muenster, muenster cheese, cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
(1)
Price: $9.35

Price: $9.35
Availability: In Stock
Laubscher Cheese

Laubscher Muenster cheese is a cheesy superstar! This American-made cheese packs a punch of mild flavor and a smooth, creamy texture. Perfect for those who love a cheese that goes with everything, Muenster is the melted cheese master, perfect for jazzing up those gooey grilled cheese sandwiches or turning those boring tuna melts into taste bud tantalizing treats! And with its bright and bold orange hue, it's not just a cheese but a feast for the eyes too!