Your cart is empty!
Get ready to stock up your shopping cart like a boss! Go on a shopping spree below, and then add all your favorite items to your cart all at once. (Note: price does not dynamically update when choosing a different size, but the shopping cart will reflect the correct price.)
Get ready for some seriously yummy butter! Our hand-rolled butter is so good, you'll want to write a rave review about it. Trust us, other customers have! It comes in a roll form, so you can effortlessly slice and measure the exact amount you need...
Monterey Jack - the delicious cheese that's a family favorite and has a smooth, mellow taste that'll make your taste buds dance! With no added color, this creamy cheese packs a flavorful punch that'll make your meals soar.
With their tangy, slightly salty flavor, cheese curds make your taste buds dance. And when you bite into one, they'll let you know they're there with a satisfying "squeak."
Middlefield's award-winning Mild Colored Cheddar is the missing piece you've been searching for! This creamy and smooth cheese is like a medium Cheddar's cool, older brother. Perfect on sandwiches, apples, crackers, or straight out of the wrapper.
This simple delight packs a punch with its fresh and tangy taste, all wrapped up in a moist yet sliceable texture. Perfect for sandwiches, crackers, or just as a snack, Farmers Cheese is sure to become your new go-to.
This cheese is like a beautiful work of art, with its stunning marbled appearance, blending the best of Colby and Monterey Jack. Not only does it look amazing, but it also tastes amazing, with a smooth and creamy texture and a mild, slightly sweet...
Feast your taste buds on the bold and spicy adventure of Pepper Jack Cheese! This cheese is a marriage of creamy Monterey Jack and sizzling jalapeño peppers that will give your taste buds a run for their money.
This fiery fusion blends smooth and creamy Monterey Jack with sizzling Habanero peppers for a flavor explosion that'll make your mouth dance. With real Habanero pieces scattered throughout, this semi-firm cheese will bring the heat to any snack or...
Smoked Pepper Jack Cheese is a flavor fiesta for your taste buds. Imagine creamy, smooth Monterey Jack cheese with a smoky twist and a kick of jalapeño peppers - it's the ultimate combo for spicy cheese lovers!
Smoked Cheddar Cheese - the perfect blend of sharpness and smokiness! Aged to perfection for a minimum of 6 months, this cheese has a creamy texture and nutty flavor. It's a smoky sensation that'll make your taste buds dance!
With its rich and bold flavor that just gets sharper with time, Sharp Cheddar is the perfect addition to any snack spread or to kick up the flavor in your favorite main dish. Its firm, yet slightly crumbly texture will tantalize your taste buds,...
This Cracker Pack is the ultimate cheese party in a box! With four delicious cheese flavors - Cheddar, Colby, Marble, and Monterey Jack - you'll be the hit of any gathering. Just grab a cracker and dive in!
Ready for a flavor adventure? Look no further than our delicious Parmesan cheese! With 12 months of aging, this cheese packs a sharp and nutty punch that will take your taste buds on a wild ride. With a slightly crumbly texture, it's perfect for...
Get ready to light up your taste buds with Marble Pepper Jack Cheese! This cheese blends the smooth and creamy goodness of Monterey Jack with the fun and playful color swirls of Colby, and adds a spicy kick of jalapeño peppers.
Introducing Amish Brick Cheese - a creamy and buttery slice of heaven! This full milk cheese has a smooth texture and a mouth-watering flavor that's perfect for pizza, sandwiches, or simply snacking on its own. The cheese gets its name from the...
Asiago is a funky, crumbly cheese that adds some serious flair to your food game! Made from cow's milk and aged to perfection, this cheese has a tangy, nutty flavor that's oh-so similar to Parmesan.
This creamy, buttery cheese is the perfect combination of flavor and texture. With a mellow taste that's similar to cheddar, you'll love how its higher moisture content gives it a softer, dreamier texture.
This Middlefield cheese is as gouda as it gets! With its smooth and supple texture, it's perfect for melting and snacking. It's like a tangy milk flavor that's playful and mild, never boring
With a creamy texture and a rich, buttery taste, Smoked Gouda is the perfect addition to any sandwich - especially burgers. What really sets this cheese apart is the gentle smoky flavor that's infused throughout. You'll love the depth and...
Middlefield Mozzarella cheese is a crowd-pleaser! This creamy and dreamy cheese is a fan favorite for a reason. Its mild, delightful flavor is perfect for snacking, and its melt-in-your-mouth texture makes it an essential ingredient for pizza and...
Shredded Middlefield Mozzarella cheese is light, airy, and ready to sprinkle its cheesy magic on anything you desire. With its creamy and mild flavor, it's the go-to cheese for pizzas and lasagnas. It's also perfect for toppings, dips, and even...
Middlefield's Fly Away Aged Cheddar Cheese is ready for takeoff with its perfectly balanced, bold flavor that will make your taste buds soar. With its firm and crumbly texture, this cheese will take you on a flavor journey with its perfect balance...
This Italian-style white cheese is the perfect mix of firm and flavorful. Think of it as Mozzarella's bold and daring cousin. Slice it for sandwiches, shred it for salads, or melt it for pizzas, this cheese will add a bold, Italian flair to any...
Looking for a cheese that's full of flavor and perfect for any occasion? Look no further than this mild jack cheese infused with buffalo wing sauce! While it won't set your mouth ablaze with heat, it will set your taste buds alight with a delicious...
Savor the true taste of India with Middlefield's Paneer Cheese. This unaged, non-melting soft cheese is meticulously crafted from pasteurized milk and vinegar, creating a firm yet creamy texture, perfect for South Asian cuisine.
Introducing Amish Brick Grass-Fed Cheese - a creamy and buttery slice of heaven! This full milk cheese has a smooth texture and a mouth-watering flavor that's perfect for pizza, sandwiches, or simply snacking on its own.
The sweet and creamy union of Colby and Monterey Jack is simply irresistible. With its swirling marbled pattern, it's not only a treat for the taste buds but a feast for the eyes too! Enjoy its mellow, smooth flavor on a sandwich, paired with your...
This classic longhorn-shaped Colby Grass-Fed Cheese is the life of the cheese party! With a texture that's softer and a flavor that's mellower and buttery compared to its close cousin, Cheddar, it's the perfect addition to your next sandwich,...
Farmers Grass-fed Cheese is a delightfully simple and straightforward cheese that is always down for a good time. It has a fresh, mild flavor with a subtle hint of tanginess and a texture that is creamy, yet firm enough to be sliced.
Our Habanero Grass-fed Cheese is a sizzling mix of creamy Monterey Jack and spicy habanero peppers. With habanero pepper pieces scattered throughout, this semi-firm cheese packs a punch of heat that will make your taste buds dance.
This amazing Marble Pepper Jack Grass-fed Cheese is the perfect mix of cool and spicy! Imagine, taking a bite of creamy, smooth Monterey Jack and Colby, then feeling the fiery kick of jalapeño peppers. It's like a party in your mouth!
Mild Colored Cheddar Grass-fed Cheese is like a goldilocks of flavor - not too strong, not too mild, but just right. Its solid texture makes it perfect for snacking, or for adding to your favorite sandwiches, apples, and crackers.
This cheese is like a secret ingredient, ready to add a touch of creamy magic to any dish it touches! Its smooth texture and subtle flavor will have you asking for seconds (or thirds, who are we kidding?).
This cheese gets better with age and its robust, tangy flavor will have you reaching for more with every bite. Perfect for slicing and serving with crackers or adding to your favorite sandwich. Plus, its traditional crumbly texture makes it a fun...
Yogurt Grass-fed Cheese is a firm white cheese with a distinct tangy, milky flavor. It contains live, active, probiotic yogurt cultures.
Get ready to add some serious sizzle to your snacking game with Smoked Cheddar Cheese! This cheesy delight is made from grass-fed cows and gets its smoky flavor from a natural hardwood infusion.
This cheese is like a medium Cheddar with a smooth, solid texture that will make your taste buds dance. Perfect on a sandwich, paired with apples and crackers, or just straight up on its own - this cheese is a party in every bite!
This mild and tangy treat is the perfect party guest, always showing up with a fresh, creamy texture that's ready to be sliced, diced, and devoured.
The marriage of Colby and Monterey Jack creates a gentle, yet irresistible flavor that will leave your taste buds dancing with joy. With its eye-catching yellow and white swirl, this cheese is not just a treat for your taste buds, but also a feast...
Farmers Goat Cheese is a delicious dance of simplicity and flavor. This fresh and mild cheese will have your taste buds doing a joyful jig with its slightly tangy taste. The texture is a perfect balance of moist and sliceable, making it a versatile...
This goat's milk smooth operator has a distinctive flavor that will add a pop of personality to any dish. With no added color, its natural deliciousness shines through. And Monterey Jack is made using a special technique called "stirred-curd" or...
Yogurt Goat Cheese is a tangy, creamy delight that's packed with probiotic goodness! It's like a healthy dose of fun for your taste buds. Use it on your favorite sandwich for a flavor explosion or enjoy it on its own as a snack.
This Amish-made treat is crafted with love, care, and the freshest goat milk from local farms. With its semi-hard texture, tangy and slightly nutty flavor, and unique taste from aging, it's like a flavor explosion in your mouth.
Colby Jack Marble Goat Cheese is a match made in cheese heaven! This creamy and smooth cheese has a love affair with your taste buds, delivering a marriage of mild, yet irresistible flavors. It's a cheese that truly has it all - the perfect...
The tangy, creamy Monterey Jack goat cheese mixed with bold jalapeño peppers is a flavor explosion waiting to happen. Perfect for those who love a little heat with their cheese.
This natural beauty is blended and smoked to perfection using real hickory wood chips, giving it a rich, smokey, melt-in-your-mouth flavor that's simply irresistible.
This cheese is the real deal, taking home the gold at the 2022 American Cheese Society Competition. It's the original recipe, perfected over time to deliver a semi-soft cheese with a mild, buttery and nutty flavor that's both rich and creamy.
Introducing the oh-so-delicious Premium Swiss from Guggisberg Cheese. This cheese will make your taste buds dance with its mild, slightly nutty flavor. You'll love it on your sandwich, sprinkled on top of your salad, or paired with a nice glass of...
This semi-soft Danish delight is the life of the party, perfect for slicing, grilling, or melting. With a smooth, rindless texture and a sunny yellow hue, Havarti is an interior-ripened cheese that is sure to please.
Say hello to the mighty, ready-to-use dry grated Parmesan. No more grating, no more fuss! Just open the bag and let the fun begin. Sprinkle it on your pasta, soups, salads, or anything that needs a cheesy kick
Perfect for those who love a cheese that goes with everything, Muenster is the melted cheese master, perfect for jazzing up those gooey grilled cheese sandwiches or turning those boring tuna melts into taste bud tantalizing treats!
This Danish delicacy packs a punch with its full-strength flavor that sets it apart from the rest. It's made using homogenized milk, giving it a sharp and slightly salty "blue bite." The cheese is crumbly with veins and pockets of blue mold, adding...
Perfect for topping burgers or making gooey grilled cheeses, this processed blend of Colby and Cheddar is a mild-mannered hero that's always in the mood for adventure.
Feast on five pounds of scrumptious Amish cheeses, including Swiss, Pepperjack, Cheddar, Colby, and Monterey Jack. But that's not all! Beef up your snacking game with mouth-watering beef sticks, and satisfy your sweet tooth with cashew crunch (or...
Sink your teeth into four pounds of heavenly Amish cheeses, including Colby, Marble, Marble Pepperjack, and Cheddar. But wait, there's more! The fun doesn't stop there! Get your munch on with mouth-watering popcorn, summer sausage, maple syrup,...
Introducing the udderly amazing cow-themed gift box, complete with artificial grass and a bounty of delicious treats. Get ready to sink your teeth into four pounds of scrumptious Amish cheeses, including Cheddar, Swiss, Marble, and Pepperjack, plus...
Say hello to the ultimate cow-themed gift box, complete with 8-oz cuts of the finest Amish cheeses and a bounty of sweet treats. Feast on 8 ounces each of CoJack Marble, Marble Pepper Jack, Farmers, Mild White Cheddar, Smoked Cheddar, Horseradish...
This delightful sausage is the epitome of snacking excellence. Take a bite and let the bold, savory flavors burst in your mouth, like a fireworks display of taste. It's the perfect addition to any meat and cheese tray, making it the star of any...
Troyer's Trail Bologna is a deliciously chunky bologna that's been slow-smoked to perfection. Made with coarse cuts of beef, this bologna is a family tradition. Pair it with Swiss Cheese, Baby Swiss Cheese, Cheddar Cheese, or Hot Pepper Cheese for...
Say hello to 1 pound of pure beefy bliss with Walnut Creek Original Beef Sticks! Made in Ohio, these beef sticks are the perfect snack for on-the-go, game day, or just because. Imagine juicy, savory beef in every bite, with a satisfying crunch in...
Keep your cheese and butter cool during the warmer months with our Styrofoam-insulated shipping carton, complete with ice packs! With room for up to 12 pounds of butter or cheese in the small carton, or 13 to 25 pounds in the large, you'll never...
Treat your loved ones to the gift of cheesy goodness! Give them the gift of a Simply Cheese Gift Certificate. Perfect for cheese lovers, foodies, or anyone who just loves a delicious snack.