Free shipping for orders over $100.00!

Use this page to order multiple items at once. Enter the quantity you want for each item then add them all at once to the cart.

Products 1-61 of 61
< Prev Next >
Amish Country Roll Butter
VARIETY:
Price: $8.59

This hand-rolled delicious butter is some of the best butter you've ever tasted. Perfect on bread, in cooking, and for eating by the slice. The unsalted variety is not quite as tasty as the salted, but the unsalted butter is perfect for baking or...

Monterey Jack
SIZE:
Price: $3.80

Monterey Jack has no added color and has a smooth, understated yet distinctive flavor that makes it perfect as a topping to virtually any dish, especially those with a Southwestern flair. The Monterey Jack variety is sometimes referred to as a...

Cheese Curds
SIZE:
Price: $3.80

Cheese Curds are squeaky fresh, delectable cheddar cheese in its natural, random shape and form before being processed into blocks of cheddar. Their flavor is mild with about the same firmness as cheese, but they have a slight rubbery texture. They...

Mild Cheddar
COLOR:
SIZE:
Price: $3.50

Middlefield's award-winning Mild Colored Cheddar Cheese is almost a medium Cheddar. Solid in texture, and very smooth, it is great on sandwiches, apples and crackers, or just for snacking. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt,...

Farmers
SIZE:
Price: $3.80

Farmers Cheese is delightfully basic and uncomplicated. It is a fresh, mild cheese with a slightly tangy taste, and a texture that is moist, yet dry enough to be sliced. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes ...

Marble
SIZE:
Price: $3.80

Colby Jack Marble Cheese is the delightful result of wedding Colby and Monterey Jack cheeses. The combination creates a gentle, savory flavor, while the mixing of the yellow and white colors gives it a visual appeal unlike any other specialty...

Pepper Jack
SIZE:
Price: $3.80

Pepper Jack Cheese is Monterey Jack cheese with the spicy "zing" of jalapeño peppers to create a flavor that both comforts and invigorates. Add Pepper Jack cheese to Southwestern recipes or simply enjoy it cubed with crackers as a...

Habanero
SIZE:
Price: $3.80

Habanero Hot Cheese is a dramatic flavor blending of savory mellow monterey jack with the spice of Habanero creating a fiery combination. A semi-firm, creamy, and very spicy cheese with Habanero pepper pieces throughout. Hot stuff! Ingredients:...

Smoked Pepper Jack
SIZE:
Price: $4.00

Smoked Pepper Jack Cheese is naturally smoked Monterey Jack cheese with Jalapeño peppers. It is the best of both worlds for the spicy cheese lover. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes, Annatto (color),...

Smoked Cheddar
SIZE:
Price: $3.80

Smoked Cheddar Cheese is infused with natural hardwood smoke to produce the distinctive flavor of this uniquely delicious cheddar. Its woodsy, mouthwatering taste is the perfect topping for your next burger or bowl of chili Ingredients: Pasteurized...

Sharp Cheddar
COLOR:
SIZE:
Price: $4.80

Sharp Colored Cheddar Cheese is rich and pungent. Its flavor becomes increasingly sharp with age. It has a firm texture, and can be slightly crumbly. Great as an appetizer or as a way to spice up a favorite main dish.Ingredients:...

Parmesan
SIZE:
Price: $4.30

This Middlefield Parmesan Cheese is out of this world! It is crazy good. It has a medium to hard texture, and is great for shredding onto salads and pasta dishes, as a topping for pizzas, or just for eating by the slice (but make them thin, because...

Marble Pepper Jack
SIZE:
Price: $3.80

Marble Pepper Jack Cheese blends Monterey Jack with Colby and adds the spicy "zing" of jalapeño peppers to create a flavor that both comforts and invigorates. Add Marble Pepper Jack cheese to Southwestern recipes or simply enjoy it...

Brick
SIZE:
Price: $3.80

Brick Cheese is a full milk brick with a creamy texture and buttery flavor. Perfect shredded on pizza or toasted on Italian bread. This creamy cheese was originally shaped and pressed with bricks, hence the name. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk,...

Asiago
SIZE:
Price: $4.30

Asiago is an aged cow's milk cheese that has a crumbly texture with a flavor reminiscent of Parmesan. This wonderful cheese is often grated in salads, soups, pastas, and sauces. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes ...

Colby Longhorn
SIZE:
Price: $3.80

Similar in flavor to Cheddar, Colby Cheese is a stirred-curd cheese made with pasteurized milk, like Monterey Jack. Colby cheese has a slightly higher moisture content than cheddar, giving it a softer texture and a mellow, buttery flavor. This...

Gouda
SIZE:
Price: $4.30

This Middlefield Gouda cheese is delicious. This young Gouda is semi-hard, with a smooth, supple, pliable texture that's ideal for melting and makes for easy snacking. Gouda has a tangy milk flavor that is approachable and mild without being...

Smoked Gouda
SIZE:
Price: $4.40

Middlefield Smoked Gouda cheese infuses traditional Goudas buttery, nutty taste with a pleasantly smoky flavor, giving this cheese remarkable depth. Its firm yet creamy quality helps to deliver a gentle smokiness to any sandwich, especially...

Mozzarella
SIZE:
Price: $4.30

Middlefield Mozzarella cheese is delicate, creamy, & mild. Most often associated with pizza & lasagna, mozzarella melts especially well. Loved by adults and kids alike, it has a mild flavor that makes it great for snacking.Ingredients: Pasteurized...

Shredded Mozzarella
SIZE:
Price: $4.30

Middlefield Mozzarella cheese is delicate, creamy, & mild. Most often associated with pizza & lasagna, mozzarella melts especially well. Loved by adults and kids alike, it has a mild flavor that makes it great for snacking.Ingredients: Pasteurized...

Fly Away Aged Cheddar
SIZE:
Price: $4.80

Middlefield's Fly Away Aged Cheddar Cheese is salty (but not too salty) and flavorful. It has a firm texture and can be slightly crumbly. This cheese has become one of our family's favorites. Try it -- you won't be disappointed. Ingredients:...

Provolone
SIZE:
Price: $7.60

Middlefield Provolone Cheese is an aged, Italian-style white cheese. It is similar to Mozzarella, but with a firmer texture and fuller flavor.

Price: $5.70

Brick Grass-fed Cheese is a full milk brick with a creamy texture and buttery flavor. Perfect shredded on pizza or toasted on Italian bread. This creamy cheese was originally shaped and pressed with bricks, hence the name.

Price: $5.70

CoJack Marble Grass-fed Cheese is the delightful result of wedding Colby and Monterey Jack cheeses. The combination creates a gentle, savory flavor, while the mixing of the yellow and white colors gives it a visual appeal unlike any other specialty...

Price: $5.70

Similar in flavor to Cheddar, Colby Grass-Fed Cheese is a stirred-curd cheese made with pasteurized milk, like Monterey Jack. Colby cheese has a slightly higher moisture content than cheddar, giving it a softer texture and a mellow, buttery flavor....

Price: $5.70

Farmers Grass-fed Cheese is delightfully basic and uncomplicated. It is a fresh, mild cheese with a slightly tangy taste, and a texture that is moist, yet dry enough to be sliced.

Price: $5.90

Habanero Grass-fed Cheese is a dramatic flavor blending of savory mellow Monterey Jack with the spice of Habanero creating a fiery combination. A semi-firm, creamy, and very spicy cheese with Habanero pepper pieces throughout. Hot stuff! 8 oz. ...

Price: $5.80

Marble Pepper Jack Grass-fed Cheese blends the mellow essence of Monterey Jack and the flavor of Colby with zesty jalapeño peppers to create a cheese that "zings." Add Pepper Jack cheese to Southwestern recipes, scrambled eggs, or...

Grass-fed Mild Cheddar 8oz
COLOR:
Price: $5.70

Mild Colored Cheddar Grass-fed Cheese is almost a medium Cheddar. Solid in texture, and very smooth, it is great on sandwiches, apples and crackers, or just for snacking.

Price: $5.70

Monterey Jack Grass-fed Cheese has no added color and has a smooth, understated yet distinctive flavor that makes it perfect as a topping to virtually any dish, especially those with a Southwestern flair. The Monterey Jack variety is sometimes...

Grass-fed Sharp Cheddar 8oz
COLOR:
Price: $6.10

Sharp Cheddar Grass-fed Cheese achieves its delicious, full-bodied flavor simply by aging longer. It's rich, pungent flavor becomes increasingly sharp with age. It has a firm texture, and can be slightly crumbly. Great as an appetizer or as a way...

Price: $6.00

Yogurt Grass-fed Cheese is a firm white cheese with a distinct tangy, milky flavor. It contains live, active, probiotic yogurt cultures. Adds a nice zip to an otherwise mild-mannered sandwich. 8 oz. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures,...

Price: $6.00

This Smoked Cheddar Cheese from grass-fed cows is infused with natural hardwood smoke to produce the distinctive flavor of this uniquely delicious cheddar. Its woodsy, mouthwatering taste is the perfect topping for your next burger or bowl of...

Organic Mild Cheddar 8oz
COLOR:
Price: $5.40

Organic Mild Colored Cheddar Cheese is almost a medium Cheddar. Solid in texture, and very smooth, it is great on sandwiches, apples and crackers, or just for snacking. Ingredients: Organic Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes, Annatto...

Price: $5.40

Organic Farmers Cheese is delightfully basic and uncomplicated. It is a fresh, mild cheese with a slightly tangy taste, and a texture that is moist, yet dry enough to be sliced. Ingredients: Organic Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes ...

Price: $5.40

Organic Colby Jack Cheese is the delightful result of wedding Colby and Monterey Jack cheeses. The combination creates a gentle, savory flavor, while the mixing of the yellow and white colors gives it a visual appeal unlike any other specialty...

Cheese Curds
SIZE:
Price: $3.80

Cheese Curds are squeaky fresh, delectable cheddar cheese in its natural, random shape and form before being processed into blocks of cheddar. Their flavor is mild with about the same firmness as cheese, but they have a slight rubbery texture. They...

Price: $5.90

Farmers Goat Cheese is delightfully basic and uncomplicated. It is a fresh, mild cheese with a slightly tangy taste, and a texture that is moist, yet dry enough to be sliced. Ingredients: Pasteurized Goat Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes. ...

Goat Mild Cheddar 8oz
COLOR:
Price: $5.90

Mild Cheddar Goat Cheese is almost a medium Cheddar. Solid in texture, and very smooth, it is great on sandwiches, apples and crackers, or just for snacking. Choose white or colored. Ingredients: Pasteurized Goat Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt,...

Price: $5.90

Monterey Jack Goat Cheese has no added color and has a smooth, understated yet distinctive flavor that makes it perfect as a topping to virtually any dish, especially those with a Southwestern flair. The Monterey Jack variety is sometimes referred...

Price: $5.90

Yogurt Goat Cheese is a firm white cheese with a distinct tangy, milky flavor. It contains live, active, probiotic yogurt cultures. Adds a nice zip to an otherwise mild-mannered sandwich. Ingredients: Pasteurized Goat Milk, Cheese Cultures,...

Price: $5.90

Brick Goat Cheese is a full milk brick with a creamy texture and buttery flavor. Perfect shredded on pizza or toasted on Italian bread. This creamy cheese was originally shaped and pressed with bricks, hence the name. Ingredients: Pasteurized Goat...

Price: $5.90

Colby Jack Marble Cheese is the delightful result of wedding Colby and Monterey Jack cheeses. The combination creates a gentle, savory flavor, while the mixing of the yellow and white colors gives it a visual appeal unlike any other specialty...

Price: $5.90

Goat Pepper Jack Cheese is Monterey Jack cheese with the spicy "zing" of jalapeño peppers to create a flavor that both comforts and invigorates. Add Pepper Jack cheese to Southwestern recipes or simply enjoy it cubed with crackers as a snack. Use...

Smoked Swiss
SIZE:
Price: $4.69

Biery's Smoked Swiss Cheese is naturally blended and smoked with real hickory wood chips in a traditional smokehouse, not sprayed on. The results give you a rich, smokey, melt-in-your-mouth flavor that's smooth and savory. The taste and aroma makes...

Guggisberg Baby Swiss
SIZE:
Price: $8.59

Original Baby Swiss by Guggisberg was awarded 1st place at the 2022 American Cheese Society Competition. It is the original Baby Swiss. It is a delicious semi-soft cheese with a buttery, subtly sweet flavor. Made with whole milk, its shorter curing...

Price: $7.89

Premium Swiss from Guggisberg Cheese. You'll love the pleasantly mild, slightly nutty flavor. Stronger than the Baby Swiss--delicious! 2022 Ohio State Fair Grand Champion2022 World Cheese Championship 2nd Place Ingredients: Pasteurized Cow's Milk,...

Price: $10.90

Havarti or Cream Havarti is a semi-soft Danish cow's milk cheese. It is a table cheese that can be sliced, grilled, or melted. Havarti is an interior-ripened cheese that is rindless, smooth, and slightly bright-surfaced with a cream to yellow...

Grated Parmesan
SIZE:
Price: $6.98

Dry grated Parmesan cheese (if you don't want to grate your own fresh Parmesan).   Ingredients: Pasteurized Part-skim Milk, Salt, less than 2% of Enzymes, Cheese Culture, Cellulose Powder to Prevent Caking, Potassium Sorbate to Protect...

Price: $7.79

Laubscher Muenster cheese is an American-made cheese. Muenster has an orange rind with interior having a white color. The orange color comes from vegetable coloring. This cheese has a mild flavor with a smooth, soft texture. This cheese is made...

Price: $11.60

Manufactured in Denmark, this is the acknowledged classic, full-strength Blue Cheese. It differs from other cheeses primarily because it is made using homogenized milk in the cheese-making process, which causes the taste to stand out. The taste is...

American Cheese
COLOR:
SIZE:
Price: $3.89

American cheese is a soft, processed cheese. It is made by the blending of Colby and Cheddar. It has a mild flavor, with a medium-firm consistency, and melts easily. Note: Contains soy ingredients.

Price: $38.99

A wonderful cow-themed gift box with artificial "grass," including four pounds of natural Amish cheeses (Cheddar, Swiss, Marble, Pepperjack) and 1 pound of Beef Sticks, along with assorted candies. Makes a great gift for Christmas, birthday,...

Price: $51.99

A wonderful cow-themed gift box with artificial "grass," including four pounds of natural Amish cheeses (Colby, Marble, Marble Pepperjack, Cheddar), popcorn, summer sausage, maple syrup, fudge, and candy. Makes a great gift for Christmas, birthday,...

Price: $62.99

A wonderful cow-themed gift box with artificial "grass," including 5 pounds of natural Amish cheeses (Swiss, Pepperjack, Cheddar, Colby, Monterey Jack), Beefsticks, Cashew Crunch (or Twizzlers), Honey, Jam, Trail Bologna, and crackers..Makes a...

Price: $36.99

A wonderful cow-themed gift box with artificial "grass," including eight cuts of natural Amish cheeses, along with assorted candies. Cheeses include 8 ounces each of CoJack Marble, Marble Pepper Jack, Farmers, Mild White Cheddar, Smoked Cheddar,...

Price: $6.90

Twelve ounces of delightful Winesburg's summer sausage. This Grand Champion Summer Sausage is a tasty snack, or include it into a complete meal! Perfect for serving as part of a meat and cheese tray.. Simply delicious! 12oz. Ingredients: Beef,...

Price: $8.69

Troyer's Trail Bologna is a wood-smoked, chunky bologna, made with coarse cuts of meat. Trail Bologna originates from the Troyer family in the tiny town of Trail, Ohio. The Troyer family has been making their quality Trail Bologna here for four...

Price: $13.25

1 pound of fresh, premium-quality Walnut Creek Original Beef Sticks, made in Ohio!Ingredients: Beef, Seasoning (Salt, Corn Syrup, Spices, Mustard, Monosodium Glutamate, Dextrose, Garlic Powder, Sodium Erythorbate), Corn Syrup Solids, Defatted Soy...

Insulated Shipping Carton
SIZE:
Price: $6.50

A Styrofoam-insulated shipping carton that will keep cheese and butter colder than if sent in a regular box. The small carton will accommodate up to 12 pounds of butter or cheese and the large holds between 13 and 25 pounds. Cold packs are...

Gift Certificate
AMOUNT:
Price: Choose Amount

Purchase a Gift Certificate for family, friends, neighbors, or co-workers. Share the goodness of Simply Cheese! A Gift Certificate code will be emailed to the recipient. Only redeemable at our online store: simplycheese.net.

Products 1-61 of 61
< Prev Next >