Indulge in the wholesome goodness of Amish cheeses from Simply Cheese! Our grass-fed cheeses are crafted with love and care by a tight-knit community of Amish farmers. They live and breathe the land, ensuring that the cows are raised with utmost care and attention, fed only the best grasses and natural forages. (:1f404:)

Every bite is bursting with rich, creamy flavor, with seasonal variations that showcase the wholesome ingredients. Embrace the traditional way of life and taste the difference in every bite! Thank you for supporting our small Amish farms!


Products 1-11 of 11
Show
Grass-Fed Brick 8oz grass fed cows, grass fed cheese, grass fed cheese brick, grass fed brick, amish grass fed cheese, grass fed, amish brick, cheese brick, natural cheese, amish natural cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
(3)
Price: $6.84

Price: $6.84
Availability: In Stock
Northeast Pastures

    Introducing Amish Brick Grass-Fed Cheese - a creamy and buttery slice of heaven! This full milk cheese has a smooth texture and a mouth-watering flavor that's perfect for pizza, sandwiches, or simply snacking on its own. The cheese gets its name from the original brick-pressing method used to shape it. Whether you're a cheese connoisseur or just a lover of delicious, wholesome food, the Amish Brick Cheese is a must-try. So go ahead, put it on your pizza, pile it on your sandwich, or enjoy it...

    Grass-fed Colby Longhorn 8oz grass fed cheese, grass fed, grass fed longhorn cheese, longhorn cheese, amish longhorn cheese, soft cheese, amish soft cheese, colby longhorn cheese, grass fed longhorn cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
    review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
    (2)
    Price: $6.84

    Price: $6.84
    Availability: Out of Stock
    Northeast Pastures

      This classic longhorn-shaped Colby Grass-Fed Cheese is the life of the cheese party! With a texture that's softer and a flavor that's mellower and buttery compared to its close cousin, Cheddar, it's the perfect addition to your next sandwich, appetizer platter, or snacking session. Don't be fooled by its smooth, creamy taste - this cheese packs a flavorful punch. So round up your cheese-lovin' friends and get ready to moo-ve and groove with this irresistible Colby Grass-Fed Cheese!Ingredients:...

      Grass-fed Farmers 8oz
      review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
      (3)
      Price: $6.84

      Price: $6.84
      Availability: In Stock
      Northeast Pastures

        Farmers Grass-fed Cheese is a delightfully simple and straightforward cheese that is always down for a good time. It has a fresh, mild flavor with a subtle hint of tanginess and a texture that is creamy, yet firm enough to be sliced. Perfect for a delicious snack or to elevate your favorite sandwich to the next level!Ingredients: Pasteurized Grass-Fed Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes

        Grass-fed Habanero 8oz habanero cheese, habanero, amish habanero, amish habanero cheese, grass fed, grass fed habanero, grass fed habanero, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
        review-star review-star review-star review-star review-star
        (1)
        Price: $7.08

        Price: $7.08
        Availability: Out of Stock
        Northeast Pastures

          Get ready for a flavor explosion! Our Habanero Grass-fed Cheese is a sizzling mix of creamy Monterey Jack and spicy habanero peppers. With habanero pepper pieces scattered throughout, this semi-firm cheese packs a punch of heat that will make your taste buds dance. Perfect for bold cheese boards or as a fiery topping for your favorite sandwich or chili. Grab a glass of milk, because this cheese is hot stuff! 🔥 8 oz. Ingredients: Pasteurized Grass-Fed Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes,...

          Grass-fed Marble
          Price: $6.84

          Price: $6.84
          Availability: In Stock
          Northeast Pastures

            CoJack Marble Grass-fed Cheese is a match made in cheese heaven! The sweet and creamy union of Colby and Monterey Jack is simply irresistible. With its swirling marbled pattern, it's not only a treat for the taste buds but a feast for the eyes too! Enjoy its mellow, smooth flavor on a sandwich, paired with your favorite fruit, or simply savor it straight from the block. This cheese is perfect for cheese lovers of all ages!Ingredients: Pasteurized Grass-Fed Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes,...

            Grass-fed Marble Pepper Jack 8oz grass fed pepper jack cheese, grass fed cheese, grass fed marble pepper jack, grass fed cheese, grass fed, pepper jack, grass fed cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
            Price: $6.96

            Price: $6.96
            Availability: Discontinued
            Northeast Pastures

              This amazing Marble Pepper Jack Grass-fed Cheese is the perfect mix of cool and spicy! Imagine, taking a bite of creamy, smooth Monterey Jack and Colby, then feeling the fiery kick of jalapeño peppers. It's like a party in your mouth! And talk about versatile! Whether you're making a spicy scrambled egg, a Southwestern dish, or a classic grilled cheese, this cheese is guaranteed to bring the heat and the flavor. So, why settle for boring cheese when you can have the "wow" factor in every bite?...

              Grass-fed Mild Cheddar 8oz grass fed mild cheddar, mild cheddar, grass fed, colored cheddar, cheddar, grass fed cheddar, amish cheddar, amish grass fed cheddar, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
              Price: $6.84

              Price: $6.84
              Availability: In Stock
              Northeast Pastures

                Looking for a cheese with just the right amount of flavor and smoothness? Look no further than Mild Colored Cheddar Grass-fed Cheese! This cheese is like a goldilocks of flavor - not too strong, not too mild, but just right. Its solid texture makes it perfect for snacking, or for adding to your favorite sandwiches, apples, and crackers. So go ahead, treat yourself to a cheesy delight that's always just right!Ingredients: Pasteurized Grass-Fed Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes, Annatto...

                Grass-fed Monterey Jack 8oz grass fed, grass fed monterey jack, monterey jack cheddar, jack cheddar, grass fed cheddar, cheddar, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
                Price: $6.84

                Price: $6.84
                Availability: In Stock
                Northeast Pastures

                  This cheese is like a secret ingredient, ready to add a touch of creamy magic to any dish it touches! Its smooth texture and subtle flavor will have you asking for seconds (or thirds, who are we kidding?). With a unique cheesemaking process, Monterey Jack Grass-fed Cheese is the perfect addition to your next southwestern fiesta. Serve it up on tacos, quesadillas, or even on its own with some crackers for a snacking extravaganza!Ingredients: Pasteurized Grass-Fed Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt,...

                  Grass-fed Sharp Cheddar 8oz grass fed, sharp colored cheddar, sharp cheddar, amish cheddar, amish sharp cheddar, amish grass fed cheddar, amish grass fed cheese, sharp colored cheddar, cheddar, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
                  Price: $7.32

                  Price: $7.32
                  Availability: In Stock
                  Northeast Pastures

                    Sharp Cheddar Grass-fed Cheese is like a fine wine, only made from milk! This cheese gets better with age and its robust, tangy flavor will have you reaching for more with every bite. Perfect for slicing and serving with crackers or adding to your favorite sandwich, this cheese is guaranteed to add a little extra "yum" to your meal. Plus, its traditional crumbly texture makes it a fun and tasty addition to any dish. So don't be afraid to go sharp and add some bold flavor to your cheese plate...

                    Grass-fed Smoked Cheddar 8oz grass fed, grass fed smoked cheese, amish grass fed cheddar, smoked cheddar, amish smoked cheddar, grass fed cheddar, amish grass fed cheese, grass fed cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me, smoked
                    Price: $7.20

                    Price: $7.20
                    Availability: In Stock
                    Middlefield Original Cheese Co-op

                      Get ready to add some serious sizzle to your snacking game with Smoked Cheddar Cheese! This cheesy delight is made from grass-fed cows and gets its smoky flavor from a natural hardwood infusion. It's like a campfire in your mouth! Perfect for jazzing up burgers or adding extra oomph to chili, this Smoked Cheddar Cheese is a real showstopper. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes, Annatto (color), Natural Wood Smoke

                      Grass-fed Yogurt Cheese 8oz grass fed yogurt cheese, yogurt cheese, grass fed, grass fed cheese, amish grass fed cheese, amish yogurt cheese, organic cheese, organic amish cheese, cheese, amish, amish farm, amish organic cheese, simply cheese, local amish cheese, amish cheese near me
                      Price: $7.20

                      Price: $7.20
                      Availability: In Stock
                      Northeast Pastures

                        Yogurt Grass-fed Cheese is a firm white cheese with a distinct tangy, milky flavor. It contains live, active, probiotic yogurt cultures. Adds a nice zip to an otherwise mild-mannered sandwich. 8 oz. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Enzymes, Salt, Acidophilus, Bifidus, and Paracacci