Welcome to Simply Cheese—where tradition, quality, and community come together. We partner with Amish and small family-run producers to bring you authentic, carefully crafted cheeses that taste as good as they’re made.
Our Story
Simply Cheese was born out of a deep appreciation for the art of cheesemaking—and a desire to support local Amish farmers. We’ve partnered with a farmer-owned co-op in Northern Ohio’s Amish country, where family-scale farms and time-honored practices are still the norm. Our goal is simple: share the outstanding flavors (and the people behind them) with cheese lovers everywhere.
What Sets Us Apart
Natural Purity
Our Amish cheeses are made with simple, traditional ingredients—focused on real dairy flavor, not fillers. We avoid unnecessary additives and artificial flavors so every bite tastes clean and authentic.
Handcrafted Excellence
Each block of Simply Cheese is made with care using time-tested methods. Crafted in small batches by skilled cheesemakers, our cheeses deliver the texture and flavor you can only get from true artisan traditions.
Time-Tested Tradition
We proudly follow Amish cheesemaking traditions passed down through generations. Every cheese reflects a deep respect for heritage—because great cheese doesn’t need shortcuts.
Unique Regional and Seasonal Flavors
From classic everyday favorites to bold specialty varieties, our lineup highlights the best of Amish-style cheesemaking. Whether you love creamy and mild or spicy and adventurous, there’s something here for your table.
Supporting Local Communities
When you choose Simply Cheese, you’re supporting small farms and local communities. Our partnership with a farmer-owned co-op helps keep traditional dairy farming strong—one order at a time.
Our Promise
We’re committed to exceptional service and cheese you’ll be proud to serve. From careful packing to temperature-conscious shipping, we do everything we can to make sure your order arrives in great condition. If there’s a problem with delivery or with the quality or condition of your cheese, we’ll make it right with a refund or reshipment.
