• Amish Country Roll Butter - Simply Cheese
  • Amish Country Roll Butter - Simply Cheese
  • Amish Country Roll Butter - Simply Cheese
1 4

Amish Country Roll Butter

Amish Country Roll Butter

Variety
$19.95 USD
$19.95 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.
  • Our Guarantee: If something goes wrong with delivery or quality, we’ll refund or reship.

Amish Country Roll Butter is a rich, old-fashioned butter known for its smooth texture and exceptional flavor. Made using a traditional family recipe dating back to 1946, this hand-packaged roll butter delivers a noticeably creamier taste than standard supermarket butter.

Unlike typical grocery store butter that contains about 80% butterfat, Amish-style roll butter is often closer to 84–85% butterfat. That higher butterfat content creates a richer flavor, smoother melt, and better performance in baking.

Crafted from a unique blend of sweet cream and whey cream sourced from high-quality dairy, each roll is carefully shaped and packaged to allow the butterfat to set evenly throughout the entire piece. The result is a consistent, velvety texture from end to end.

Perfect for:

  • Spreading on warm bread or bagels
  • Melting over pancakes and vegetables
  • Baking flaky pie crusts and pastries
  • Serving at the table as an everyday butter

If you’re wondering what makes Amish Country Roll Butter different, it’s the combination of higher butterfat, traditional methods, and careful hand packaging that gives it that rich, creamy flavor people rave about.

Experience the old-world taste that has made Amish Country Roll Butter a customer favorite across the country.

Want to Learn More?

Curious what makes roll butter different from standard grocery store butter?
Read our guide: What Is Amish Country Roll Butter? (And Why It Tastes Different).

  • Salted Butter: Pasteurized Cream, Salt.
  • Unsalted Butter: Pasteurized Cream, Natural Flavorings

Best For: Spreading on bread, baking, cooking Flavor: Rich, creamy, slightly sweet Source: Churned cream Pairings: Freshly baked bread, roasted vegetables, or herbal tea Texture: Smooth and spreadable

Transparency note: Alcam Creamery estimates that about 85% of the milk used for this butter comes from Amish farms (they’re located in Amish country). We carry it because it’s exceptionally flavorful—but it’s not a 100% Amish product.

View full details

FAQs

What is Amish Country Roll Butter?

Amish Country Roll Butter is traditional-style butter sold in a large roll instead of sticks. It’s prized for its rich, creamy flavor and smooth texture—great for everyday table use, cooking, and baking.

Why does Amish roll butter taste different from regular butter?

Many customers notice a richer, more old-fashioned butter flavor and a creamier mouthfeel than typical grocery-store butter. The roll format and traditional-style handling help create a smooth, consistent texture throughout.

How should I store Amish Country Roll Butter?

Keep it refrigerated. For best spreadability, you can let a small portion soften at room temperature before serving, then return the rest to the refrigerator.

What is Amish Country Roll Butter best used for?

It’s perfect for spreading on bread, toast, or bagels; melting over pancakes, potatoes, and vegetables; cooking; and baking when you want a rich butter flavor.

Do you ship Amish Country Roll Butter nationwide?

Yes—we ship nationwide. Shipping timing and details are available at checkout and on our Shipping & Returns page.

  • 5 stars: 49 (100%)
  • 4 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 3 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
A
Anonymous
The best

The best!!

R
ROBIN C.
Absolutely the best butter ever

Absolutely the best butter ever. Friends and family always comment on how delicious it is.

A
Anonymous
The best tasting butter we ever had ! So fresh and creamy

The best tasting butter we ever had ! So fresh and creamy. We are hooked on it now !

J
Jonathan
A Kitchen Staple

A must have in every kitchen! Delicious!

L
Lisa T.
So much better than store bought butter.

This is the best butter, I haven't found butter this good in a long time. I have been using it for my holiday baking cakes & cookies, it's good on biscuits & muffins. My husband says it tastes like the butter his mom used to make when he was little. I will keep buying this butter, it is so much better than store bought butter.

F
Floyd
Great Butter

I like the taste of this butter; it is salted and goes good with my waffles and eggs. Cooking with it adds a good taste to my food.

D
Dave
Great taste and creamy

Great taste and creamy

S
Swati B.
We love it!

We love it!!

P
Phillis
Best butter ever

So glad that I found this butter on your site. It is the best butter we have ever had. My whole family enjoys it. I make sure I don't run out!

P
PC
Loved the country roll butter unsalted

Loved the country roll butter unsalted but seems the rates have gone up by $1 for each lb.

K
Kjb
Wonderful, as Always!!

If you've never tried this butter, you do not know what you are missing! It is delicious on (and in) EVERYTHING!!

W
Wanda C.
No better butter in the world

There is no better butter in the world. Absolutely love it and have been buying it for several years.

D
Donna G.
Your butter makes everything taste better, and I'm eating something natural, not plastic!

Having your butter available every day is a big part of our meals. Everyone that visits asks me if we still have the good butter. I always say absolutely!!

R
RJZ
Awesome Butter, delicious!

Delicious butter, real butter and I am happy to support the Amish families who supply the milk and labor to make this butter. Thank you to all.

M
Marilyn W.
This butter is wonderful!

I live in south central Texas! I always order this butter in November when it gets a little cooler! Have never been dissatisfied with my shipment! Always nice and cold. This butter is wonderful! I ordered enough to last me until next November!

A
Amish R.B.
Love Amish butter

Always arrives on time and exactly the same as if I went to Shipshewana to buy.

C
Cats
Absolutely the best ever!

The butter is absolutely the best ever!!

S
Sandi W.
Best butter I have tasted in ages!

So happy to have found Amish Roll butter at Simply Cheese. Ordering was very easy and shipping was fast. The butter is wonderful! Will definitely be purchasing again!

T
TD
My Favorite Butter

We love this butter. We also have given it as gifts for the last two years and our friends rave about how delicious it is. Best butter ever!

M
Mtnboy
Amish butter is great

The product is great. I have been buying it for years. The shipping was bad as there was only one freezer bag and very little newspaper for insulation.

R
Robin
Best butter ever

Absolutely the best ever. You will never want store bought sticks of butter after using this. Delicious on everything.

R
Regina
BEST Butter

Some friends introduced us to this wonderful butter--Amish Roll Butter in 2 lb. rolls. We fell in love with it immediately! It is the BEST butter ever.

B
BusyBee
Soooo Yummy

This is the best butter ever. It's like making your own. Very creamy. So good you want to eat it by the slice.

K
Kathey
Only butter I use

My Aunt Tootsie used to rave about Amish butter. When I saw this butter in Simply Cheese, I decided to give it a try. Aunt Tootsie was right! Creamier and better tasting than store bought butter. I'm starting to stock up on it now to put in the freezer so I don't run out.

L
Love2Eat
Awesome

The best tasting butter I've had in years. The color and texture are incredible and the taste UNBEATABLE. In a word, OUTSTANDING.

D
DIANE
GREAT !!

THE BUTTER... is great! We received it and was still firm. We freeze our butter and use it all year. Served it today at Thanksgiving. GREAT REVIEWS.

D
D. G.
Love this Butter

My husband and I absolutely love this Butter... It is always noticed by our guests. We hope we never have to do without it... My baking is much improved when is use it in my baked goods...

c
cheryl
Love the Amish butter

Love the Amish butter.

R
Rosemary P.
I love this butter!

I love this butter! I only wish I could get it locally in Minnesota and not have to pay for shipping. I also wish it came in quarters so I could get accurate measurements when baking with it. The container when it is hot outside works fairly well. Not really that good.

J
John M.
Executive Chef Approval!

Our former Executive Chef was amazed with the flavor of this butter. Both the Salted and Unsalted are the best we have ever tasted. Will keep in our kitchen for years to come!

L
Linda
Closest I've found to farm fresh butter

This butter is wonderful. It is the closest I have found to farm fresh butter. I load up my freezer so I don't run out.

E
Eric
This butter has outstanding taste

This is the second time that I have placed an order with Simply Cheese and have not been disappointed. Shipment is fast and the butter is delicious.

L
Lori H.
Love it!

Very tasty!