Milked by hand

Cows are milked by hand on small Amish family farms.

Horse and buggy

Fresh milk goes to the creamery in traditional metal tins, by horse-drawn buggy.

Shipped fresh

We ship Monday through Wednesday, so your cheese never sits in a warehouse over the weekend.

Our guarantee

If there's ever an issue with delivery or quality, we'll refund or reship. No hassle.

Classic Amish Gift Box - Simply Cheese

 Build an Amish Cheese Gift Box 

Pick every cheese and every meat, add your personal message, and we’ll pack it in a gift box ready to give. Real Amish cheese from family farms, never processed blends. Boxes start at $49.95.

Build Your Gift Box

Shipped Fresh  |  Handcrafted  |  Small-Batch  |  Simple Ingredients

Amish farmhouse with red barn and horse-drawn carriage

Who We Are

Simply Cheese brings you cheese directly from small, traditional Amish creameries in Geauga County, Ohio and Lancaster County, Pennsylvania.

Cows are milked by hand, fresh milk is delivered by horse-drawn buggy in traditional metal tins, and cheesemaking follows methods passed down through generations.

No shortcuts. No compromises. Just honest, authentic cheese made the way it has always been made.

Read More

FAQs

Where can I buy authentic Amish cheese online?

Right here. Since 2008 we’ve brought cheese straight from small Amish family creameries in Ohio and Pennsylvania to kitchens across the country. That includes traditional favorites, grass-fed varieties, raw milk cheddar and goat cheese.

Do you ship Amish butter and meats nationwide?

Yes. We ship our Amish roll butter, meats and cheese to the lower 48 states. Orders go out Monday through Wednesday so nothing sits in a warehouse over the weekend, and orders over $99 ship free.

What makes Amish cheese different from store-bought?

It comes from small family farms, where cows are still milked by hand and the cheese is made the same way it has been for generations. You taste the difference in every bite.