Assorted types of cheese with bread, fruits, and honey on a wooden table.

Authentic Amish Cheese from Ohio's Amish Country

Small-batch Amish cheese made in Ohio using traditional methods and simple ingredients.

Shop Traditional Cheese

Simply Cheese brings you authentic Amish cheese made in small batches in Ohio’s Amish country. From traditional cheddar and Monterey Jack to grass-fed and goat milk varieties, every cheese is handcrafted and shipped fresh to your door.

Our Guarantee: If there’s ever an issue with delivery or quality, we’ll refund or reship.

Shipped Fresh  |  Handcrafted  |  Small-Batch  |  Simple Ingredients

Collections

Rated 4.99 by 170+ Verified Customers

4.99 ★ (172)
Verified

Top Rated Favorites

Our most loved products, chosen by customers across the country.

1 8
Amish farmhouse with red barn and horse-drawn carriage

Who We Are

We partner with Amish and small family dairies that still value careful workmanship, simple ingredients, and time-honored methods.

Read More