Genuinely Amish. Not Just Amish Country.

There's a difference between cheese made in Amish Country and cheese made by the Amish — and you can taste it.

Shop Amish Cheeses

Simply Cheese brings you cheese directly from small, traditional Amish creameries in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania and Geauga County, Ohio — where cows are milked by hand, fresh milk is delivered by horse-drawn buggy in traditional metal tins, and cheesemaking follows methods passed down through generations. No shortcuts. No compromise. Just honest, authentic cheese made the way it has always been made.

These are not commercial products branded with a barn and a bonnet. These are the real thing — small-batch, handcrafted cheeses from families who have been doing this long before "artisan" became a marketing term.

Our Guarantee: If there’s ever an issue with delivery or quality, we’ll refund or reship.

Shipped Fresh  |  Handcrafted  |  Small-Batch  |  Simple Ingredients

Collections

Rated 4.99 by 170+ Verified Customers

4.99 ★ (175)
Verified

Top Rated Favorites

Our most loved products, chosen by customers across the country.

1 8
Amish farmhouse with red barn and horse-drawn carriage

Who We Are

We partner with Amish and small family dairies that still value careful workmanship, simple ingredients, and time-honored methods.

Read More