Build Your Perfect Amish Cheese Bundle
There’s something special about cheese made the traditional way —small batches, real milk, and time-honored Amish craftsmanship.
Build your own bundle from 7 themed bundles of our authentic Amish-made cheeses and save as you choose your favorites.
🎉Choose a minimum of 4 cheeses to activate your discount.🎉
How It Works
Mix and match freely within each of the 7 bundles below.
Sizes vary by cheese (6 oz, 8 oz, and 1 lb cuts), with pricing shown for each item.
Enjoy free shipping on orders over $99.
Start with one of the bundles below and choose your favorites.
Most Popular
Amish Classics
The perfect starting point — mild, creamy, and unmistakably fresh.
Choose from: Colby Longhorn, Mild Cheddar, Farmers, Provolone, Brick, Marble, Monterey Jack, Gouda & more
Build your collection: 4+ cheeses save 10% · 6+ save 15%
Build Your Bundle →
Flavor & Flair
Bold flavors, unexpected combinations, and cheeses worth talking about.
Choose from: Garlic & Herb, Dilly Pickle, Smoky Apple Jack, Sweet Heat, Pepperoncini Jack, Olive & Pepperoncini & more
Build your collection: 4+ cheeses save 10% · 6+ save 15%
Build Your Bundle →
Bold & Spicy
You know what you like — heat, smoke, and a little attitude. Build your perfect lineup of Amish-made fire.
Choose from: Pepper Jack, Habanero Pepper Jack, Smoked Pepper Jack, Buffalo Jack, Marble Pepper Jack & more
Build your collection: 4+ cheeses save 10% · 6+ save 15%
Build Your Bundle →Specialty
From the Pasture
Richer, cleaner milk from cows raised on open pasture — you can taste the difference. Every cheese here is 100% grass-fed.
Choose from: Grass-Fed Mild Cheddar, Sharp Cheddar, Smoked Cheddar, Colby Longhorn, Farmers, Marble, Monterey Jack & more
Build your collection: 4+ cheeses save 10% · 6+ save 15%
Build Your Bundle →
Simply Goat
Lighter, tangier, and distinct in all the right ways. Our goat milk cheeses are made by the same Amish hands — just from a different herd.
Choose from: Goat Brick, Farmers, Marble, Colby Longhorn, Pepper Jack, Monterey Jack & more
Build your collection: 4+ cheeses save 10% · 6+ save 15%
Build Your Bundle →
Aged & Artisan
For the cheese board builder and the dinner party host. Complex, layered flavors that stand on their own.
Choose from: Fly Away Aged Cheddar, Sharp Cheddar, Asiago, Parmesan, Smoked Swiss, Baby Swiss & more
Build your collection: 4+ cheeses save 10% · 6+ save 15%
Build Your Bundle →Premium
The Cheddar Cellar
Our most exceptional line — raw milk cheddars aged from 6 to 36 months, crafted by Amish artisans in Lancaster County. As they age, these cheeses develop depth, complexity, and the crystalline texture cheese lovers seek. Perfect for gifting, entertaining, or building an exceptional cheese board.
Build your collection: 4+ cheeses save 10% · 6+ save 15%
Aged Classics
Flavor Infusions
Build Your Bundle →
