Amish Cheese Gift Boxes

Amish cheese gift box filled with real Amish cheese blocks, summer sausage and holiday candies

Amish Cheese Gift Boxes

Most cheese gift boxes come pre-packed with whatever the warehouse put in them. Ours start with you. You pick every cheese and every meat, add your personal message, and we pack it into a gift box with festive shred and hard candies, ready to give.

And it's real cheese. Every block comes from milk produced by Amish family farms and made into cheese by a farmer-owned dairy cooperative. No processed cheese "blends," no fillers, no shortcuts.

Small Gift Box

You pick 3 cheeses + 1 meat

$49.95 + $9.95 flat-rate shipping

A great fit for a coworker, a neighbor, a teacher, or a first taste of real Amish cheese.

Build the Small Box →

Large Gift Box

You pick 5 cheeses + 2 meats

$74.95 + $9.95 flat-rate shipping

Our most generous box, for a family, an office, or someone who deserves the full spread.

Build the Large Box →

What's Inside

We list weights so you know exactly what you're sending.

  Small Box Large Box
Cheese 3 blocks, 8 oz each (1.5 lb) 5 blocks, 8 oz each (2.5 lb)
Meat 1 of your choice 2 of your choice
Extras Gift box, festive shred, hard candies, and your personal message

Meat choices:

  • Trail Bologna, 20 oz: smoky, all-beef, and an Amish country classic
  • Summer Sausage, 12 oz
  • Smoked Meat Sticks, 9 oz

Why Our Boxes Are Different

  • Real cheese, never processed. Many big-brand gift boxes use processed cheese "blends" made with added water and emulsifiers. Ours is real Amish cheese, the kind we've been selling since 2008.
  • You choose. Know they love Swiss but can't stand spicy? Build the box around them, then add a personal message.
  • Generous sizes. Full 8 oz blocks of cheese and meats up to 20 oz, not sample-size wedges.
  • Shipped fresh. We ship Monday through Wednesday so your gift never sits in a warehouse over the weekend.

How It Works

  1. Choose the Small or Large box.
  2. Pick your cheeses, then your meats.
  3. Write a personal message for your recipient.
  4. Check out. We pack it, add the shred and candies, and ship it straight to your recipient.

Prefer a Ready-Made Box?

If you'd rather let us choose, our pre-packed gift boxes are ready to go:

Gift Box Questions

Is this real cheese?
Yes. Every block is natural cheese made from milk produced by Amish family farms. We don't sell processed cheese or cheese "blends."

How much does shipping cost?
Every gift box ships for a flat $9.95.

When will it ship?
We ship Monday through Wednesday so your box arrives fresh. Order early in December to make sure it arrives before Christmas.

Should the recipient refrigerate it?
Yes. Pop the cheese and meat in the refrigerator when the box arrives.

Build a Small Box → Build a Large Box →