What is Amish Country Roll Butter?

Amish Country Roll Butter is a traditional-style butter sold in a large roll instead of sticks. It’s known for a rich, creamy flavor and an old-fashioned texture that many customers prefer for table use, cooking, and baking.

Why does Amish roll butter taste different from regular butter?

Many people notice a richer, creamier flavor compared to typical grocery-store butter. Roll butter is often associated with traditional methods and careful handling that produce a smooth texture and fuller taste.

Is Amish Country Roll Butter salted?

Check the product options on this page for salted vs. unsalted availability. The selected variant and label indicate whether it is salted.

How should I store Amish Country Roll Butter?

Keep it refrigerated. For best flavor and spreadability, you can let a small amount soften at room temperature before serving, then return the rest to the refrigerator.

What is Amish Country Roll Butter best used for?

It’s great for spreading on bread or bagels, melting over pancakes and vegetables, cooking, and baking (especially when you want a rich butter flavor).

Where do you ship Amish Country Roll Butter?

We ship nationwide. Shipping details and timing are shown at checkout and in our shipping information.

1 4

Sharp Cheddar

Size 8oz 1lb 5lb

Color White Colored

$5.95 USD

Sale Sold out

Shipping calculated at checkout.

Our Guarantee: If something goes wrong with delivery or quality, we’ll refund or reship.

Sharp Cheddar Cheese delivers a bold, tangy bite with a firm texture that slices cleanly and melts beautifully. As it ages, the flavor becomes more intense, adding depth to everything from sandwiches to casseroles. It’s a staple for cheese boards, comfort-food recipes, and anyone who loves a cheddar with real character.

Great For Grilled Cheese
Sharp Cheddar melts beautifully and adds bold flavor. Want to see how it compares to other melters? Read our best cheese for grilled cheese guide.

Enjoy it sliced with crackers and fruit, grated over hot pasta or chili, or melted into grilled cheese, burgers, and baked dishes for an extra punch of flavor.

Pasteurized Milk, Cheese Cultures, Salt, Enzymes, Annatto (color)

Best For: Cheese trays, grating over dishes Flavor: Robust, tangy, and sharp Milk Type: Cow's milk Pairings: Pear slices, walnuts, or Cabernet Sauvignon Texture: Firm and slightly crumbly

View full details

5 stars: 5 (100%)
4 stars: 0 (0%)
3 stars: 0 (0%)
2 stars: 0 (0%)
1 star: 0 (0%)

Best Cheddar

Awesome tasting cheddar for Tacos and Macaroni and Cheese. Just Perfect.

Lovely Table Cheddar

This is a good everyday table cheese. It is rich, creamy, and flavorful with enough bite to know you're eating cheddar! It does not compete with some extremely sharp cheddars that have had longer aging, but makes an absolutely wonderful baked mac and cheese, particularly if you can find boneless/skinless ham hocks to dice into the mix. For the price, it can be a pleasure that you can enjoy daily. It is healthy, and not GMO.

Husband approved

This my hubby's favorite.....great snacker.

Great grilled cheese

Made a great grilled cheese.

Truly the best cheese.

This sharp white cheddar is truly the best. Pure and simple. Delicious and flavorful. My granddaughters (ages 2 and 4) request this cheese every time they visit.

Your cart is empty

All Cheese

All Cheese

Your cart

Estimated total

Sharp Cheddar

Sharp Cheddar

Join Our Cheese Club

Sharp Cheddar

Sharp Cheddar

Share this product

Sharp Cheddar Cheese | Simply Cheese