Collection: All Cheese
All of our cheeses are selected for quality, tradition, and great flavor.
We specialize in Amish-made cheeses crafted in small batches using time-honored methods, and we also carry a limited number of specialty cheeses by request from our customers. Whether you’re building a snack board, planning a meal, or shopping for a gift, you’ll find cheeses here that are simple, honest, and delicious.
Traditional Cheese | Grass-fed Cheese | Raw Cheddar Cheese | Goat Cheese
-
Smoky Apple Jack
Smooth Jack with sweet, smoky apple notes—perfect for boards, melts.
No reviewsRegular price $6.25 USDRegular priceSale price $6.25 USD -
36 Month Crescendo Raw Milk Cheddar
Raw milk cheddar aged a full 36 months — boldly sharp, gloriously crumbly, and packed with flavor.
1 review5.0 / 5.0
(1) 1 total reviews
Regular price $9.95 USDRegular priceSale price $9.95 USD -
Bloomy Rind Raw Milk Cheddar 6mo
Raw milk cheddar aged 6 months with a soft, natural bloomy rind — creamy, earthy, and utterly unique.
No reviewsRegular price $9.55 USDRegular priceSale price $9.55 USD -
Buffalo Jack
Creamy Jack with buffalo-style kick—made for wraps, quesadillas, nachos.
No reviewsRegular price From $5.10 USDRegular priceSale price From $5.10 USD -
Goat Pepper Jack
Goat milk Pepper Jack with gentle kick—perfect for tacos, grilled cheese.
No reviewsRegular price $7.75 USDRegular priceSale price $7.75 USD -
Grated Parmesan
Bold, salty grated Parmesan—ready to sprinkle on pasta, soups, salads.
No reviewsRegular price From $5.35 USDRegular priceSale price From $5.35 USD -
Pepperoncini Jack
Tangy pepperoncini Jack with mild heat—great for wraps, sliders, melts.
No reviewsRegular price $6.25 USDRegular priceSale price $6.25 USD -
Shredded Cheddar
Cheddar shreds, ready fast—great for tacos, chili, baked potatoes.
No reviewsRegular price From $5.20 USDRegular priceSale price From $5.20 USD -
Peppercorn Raw Milk Cheddar 6mo
Raw milk cheddar aged 6 months, studded with a bold cracked mixed peppercorn blend..
1 review5.0 / 5.0
(1) 1 total reviews
Regular price $7.95 USDRegular priceSale price $7.95 USD -
Premium Swiss
Smooth, nutty Swiss with a clean finish—perfect for sandwiches, fondue.
1 review5.0 / 5.0
(1) 1 total reviews
Regular price $10.35 USDRegular priceSale price $10.35 USD -
Marble Pepper Jack
Marble cheese with a peppery kick—great for tacos, casseroles, dips.
No reviewsRegular price From $5.10 USDRegular priceSale price From $5.10 USD -
Habanero Raw Milk Cheddar 6mo
Raw milk cheddar aged 6 months, infused with real habanero peppers for a fruity, fiery kick.
No reviewsRegular price $7.95 USDRegular priceSale price $7.95 USD -
Smoked Swiss
Nutty Swiss with bold smoky finish—perfect for sandwiches, hearty melts.
No reviewsRegular price $10.35 USDRegular priceSale price $10.35 USD -
Smoky Pepper Jack
Smoky Pepper Jack with a creamy kick—made for burgers, nachos.
No reviewsRegular price $6.25 USDRegular priceSale price $6.25 USD -
Sundried Tomato & Basil — Flatbread Fontina
Creamy, melty fontina with sweet sundried tomato and fragrant basil — endlessly versatile.
No reviewsRegular price $8.95 USDRegular priceSale price $8.95 USD -
Olive & Pepperoncini — Flatbread Fontina
Creamy, melty fontina with briny kalamata olives and tangy pepperoncini.
No reviewsRegular price $8.95 USDRegular priceSale price $8.95 USD
Browse Other Collections
-
Traditional Cheese
Our Traditional Amish cheese collection features the classic flavors and handcrafted quality...
-
Grass-fed Cheese
Our grass-fed cheese collection features handcrafted cheeses made from milk sourced from...
-
Goat Cheese
Discover our handcrafted goat cheese collection, made in Northern Ohio’s Amish country...
-
Amish Gifts
Our Amish cheese gift boxes and bags make it easy to send...
-
Snack Sticks & Sausages
Satisfy your cravings with our delicious selection of smoked beef sticks, summer...