Collection: All Cheese
All of our cheeses are selected for quality, tradition, and great flavor.
We specialize in Amish-made cheeses crafted in small batches using time-honored methods, and we also carry a limited number of specialty cheeses by request from our customers. Whether you’re building a snack board, planning a meal, or shopping for a gift, you’ll find cheeses here that are simple, honest, and delicious.
Traditional Cheese | Grass-fed Cheese | Raw Cheddar Cheese | Goat Cheese
-
Mozzarella
Mild, stretchy mozzarella—made for pizza, baked pasta, casseroles, cheesy pulls.
1 review5.0 / 5.0
(1) 1 total reviews
Regular price From $5.50 USDRegular priceSale price From $5.50 USD -
Cracker Pak
Grab-and-go cheese and cracker pack—perfect for lunchboxes, road trips.
No reviewsRegular price From $5.10 USDRegular priceSale price From $5.10 USD -
Mild Cheddar
Creamy mild cheddar that melts beautifully—great for sandwiches, snacking.
2 reviews5.0 / 5.0
(2) 2 total reviews
Regular price From $4.85 USDRegular priceSale price From $4.85 USD -
Asiago
Sharp, nutty Asiago—great for shaving, grating, or bold snacking slices.
4 reviews4.75 / 5.0
(4) 4 total reviews
Regular price From $5.50 USDRegular priceSale price From $5.50 USD -
Garlic & Herb
Savory garlic-and-herb cheese—excellent with crackers, pasta, veggies.
No reviewsRegular price $6.25 USDRegular priceSale price $6.25 USD -
Brick
Mild, buttery Brick cheese with great melt—perfect for pizza, bakes, sandwiches.
7 reviews5.0 / 5.0
(7) 7 total reviews
Regular price From $4.85 USDRegular priceSale price From $4.85 USD -
Grass-fed Brick
Grass-fed Brick cheese with buttery melt—perfect for pizza, bakes, sandwiches.
1 review5.0 / 5.0
(1) 1 total reviews
Regular price From $6.25 USDRegular priceSale price From $6.25 USD -
Grass-fed Pepper Jack
Grass-fed Pepper Jack with creamy heat—perfect for nachos, burgers.
No reviewsRegular price From $6.35 USDRegular priceSale price From $6.35 USD -
Horseradish Cheese
Creamy cheese with horseradish zing—perfect for roast beef, sliders.
No reviewsRegular price From $5.10 USDRegular priceSale price From $5.10 USD -
Goat Yogurt Cheese
Tangy, creamy goat yogurt cheese—perfect for spreading with fruit, honey.
No reviewsRegular price $7.55 USDRegular priceSale price $7.55 USD -
Grass-fed Monterey Jack
Grass-fed Jack with smooth, creamy flavor—perfect for tacos, melts.
No reviewsRegular price From $6.25 USDRegular priceSale price From $6.25 USD -
Pepper Jack
Creamy Pepper Jack with lively heat—great for burgers, nachos, tacos.
8 reviews5.0 / 5.0
(8) 8 total reviews
Regular price From $5.10 USDRegular priceSale price From $5.10 USD -
Shredded Mozzarella
Ready-to-use mozzarella shreds—perfect for pizza night, quick bakes.
No reviewsRegular price From $5.85 USDRegular priceSale price From $5.85 USD -
Dilly Pickle
Zesty dill pickle flavor in a creamy cheese—great on crackers, sandwiches.
No reviewsRegular price $6.25 USDRegular priceSale price $6.25 USD -
Goat Brick
Creamy goat milk Brick cheese—melts well for sandwiches, burgers, easy meals.
8 reviews5.0 / 5.0
(8) 8 total reviews
Regular price $7.55 USDRegular priceSale price $7.55 USD -
Goat Farmers
Mild, creamy goat milk Farmers cheese—perfect for slicing, melting, snacking.
3 reviews5.0 / 5.0
(3) 3 total reviews
Regular price $7.55 USDRegular priceSale price $7.55 USD
Browse Other Collections
-
Traditional Cheese
Our Traditional Amish cheese collection features the classic flavors and handcrafted quality...
-
Grass-fed Cheese
Our grass-fed cheese collection features handcrafted cheeses made from milk sourced from...
-
Goat Cheese
Discover our handcrafted goat cheese collection, made in Northern Ohio’s Amish country...
-
Amish Gifts
Our Amish cheese gift boxes and bags make it easy to send...
-
Snack Sticks & Sausages
Satisfy your cravings with our delicious selection of smoked beef sticks, summer...