-
Sweet Heat
Sweet up front with gentle heat—perfect for boards, melts, party bites.
Regular price $6.25 USDRegular price -
Farmers
Mild, creamy Farmers cheese—slices and melts easily for everyday snacking.
Regular price From $4.85 USDRegular price -
Habanero Pepper Jack
Creamy Jack with real habanero heat—perfect for nachos, burgers.
Regular price From $5.10 USDRegular price -
6 Month Classic Raw Milk Cheddar
Raw-milk cheddar aged 6 months for classic cheddar sweetness and a smooth, melty bite.
Regular price $7.95 USDRegular price -
American
Classic, creamy American-style cheese—made for smooth melts and burgers.
Regular price $9.45 USDRegular price -
Goat Monterey Jack
Smooth, creamy goat milk Jack—perfect for tacos, quesadillas, melting.
Regular price $7.55 USDRegular price -
Muenster
Mild, buttery, ultra-melty Muenster—made for grilled cheese, burgers.
Regular price From $4.55 USDRegular price -
Paneer
Firm, mild Paneer that sears without melting—perfect for curries, grilling.
Regular price From $5.50 USDRegular price -
Goat Mild White Cheddar
Mild, creamy goat milk white cheddar—perfect for snacking, lunch slices.
Regular price $7.55 USDRegular price -
Grass-fed Marble
Grass-fed Marble blend—mild, creamy, perfect for sandwiches and melting.
Regular price From $6.25 USDRegular price -
Smoked Cheddar
Rich cheddar with bold smoke flavor—ideal for mac & cheese, burgers.
Regular price $6.25 USDRegular price -
9 Month Mature Raw Milk Cheddar
Raw milk cheddar aged 9 months for bold, sharp flavor and a satisfyingly firm bite.
Regular price $8.25 USDRegular price -
24 Month Virtuoso Raw Milk Cheddar
Raw milk cheddar aged 24 months for intense sharpness, complex flavor, and satisfying tyrosine crystals.
Regular price $9.55 USDRegular price -
12 Month Vintage Raw Milk Cheddar
Raw milk cheddar aged 12 months for bold, sharp flavor and a satisfyingly firm bite.
Regular price $8.45 USDRegular price -
Goat Marble
Goat milk Marble blend—mild, creamy, and versatile for boards and melts.
Regular price $7.55 USDRegular price -
Grass-fed Horseradish
Grass-fed cheese with horseradish bite—perfect for sliders, roast beef.
Regular price From $6.35 USDRegular price
Browse Other Collections
-
Traditional Cheese
Our Traditional Amish cheese collection features the classic flavors and handcrafted quality...
-
Grass-fed Cheese
Our grass-fed cheese collection features handcrafted cheeses made from milk sourced from...
-
Goat Cheese
Discover our handcrafted goat cheese collection, made in Northern Ohio’s Amish country...
-
Amish Gifts
Our Amish cheese gift boxes and bags make it easy to send...
-
Snack Sticks & Sausages
Satisfy your cravings with our delicious selection of smoked beef sticks, summer...
