-
Peppercorn Raw Milk Cheddar 6mo
Raw milk cheddar aged 6 months, studded with a bold cracked mixed peppercorn blend..
Regular price $7.95 USDRegular price -
Pepperoncini Jack
Tangy pepperoncini Jack with mild heat—great for wraps, sliders, melts.
Regular price $6.25 USDRegular price -
Pepperoni & Roasted Red Pepper — Flatbread Fontina
Creamy, melty fontina packed with pepperoni and sweet roasted red pepper.
Regular price $8.95 USDRegular price -
Premium Swiss
Smooth, nutty Swiss with a clean finish—perfect for sandwiches, fondue.
Regular price $10.35 USDRegular price -
Provolone
Mild, smooth Provolone with gentle tang—perfect for sandwiches, melts.
Regular price From $5.50 USDRegular price -
Sharp Cheddar
Bold, tangy sharp cheddar with rich finish—perfect for mac & cheese, boards.
Regular price From $5.95 USDRegular price -
Shredded Cheddar
Cheddar shreds, ready fast—great for tacos, chili, baked potatoes.
Regular price From $5.20 USDRegular price -
Shredded Mozzarella
Ready-to-use mozzarella shreds—perfect for pizza night, quick bakes.
Regular price From $5.85 USDRegular price -
Signature Amish Gift Box
Well-rounded box of Amish best-sellers—perfect for families, gatherings.
Regular price $72.99 USDRegular price -
Simply Cheese Gift Card
The perfect gift for cheese lovers—let them choose their favorites anytime.
Regular price From $10.00 USDRegular price -
Sliced Pepperoni
Bold pepperoni slices—ready for pizza, charcuterie, quick snacking.
Regular price $15.95 USDRegular price -
Smoked Cheddar
Rich cheddar with bold smoke flavor—ideal for mac & cheese, burgers.
Regular price $6.25 USDRegular price -
Smoked Meat Sticks
Smoky, savory meat sticks—perfect for road trips, lunchboxes, snacks.
Regular price $8.95 USDRegular price -
Smoked Pepper Jack
Smoked Pepper Jack with creamy heat—perfect for quesadillas, dips, burgers.
Regular price From $5.40 USDRegular price -
Smoked Raw Milk Cheddar 6mo
Raw milk cheddar aged 6 months, infused with natural applewood smoke flavor for a rich, smoky depth.
Regular price $7.95 USDRegular price -
Smoked Swiss
Nutty Swiss with bold smoky finish—perfect for sandwiches, hearty melts.
Regular price $10.35 USDRegular price
Browse Other Collections
-
Traditional Cheese
Since 2008, we've partnered with Amish and small family-run producers in Northern...
-
Grass-fed Cheese
Handcrafted from milk sourced from pasture-raised cows in Northern Ohio's Amish country,...
-
Goat Cheese
Made in Northern Ohio's Amish country using traditional small-batch methods, our goat...
-
Amish Gifts
Handcrafted Amish cheeses, thoughtfully assembled and shipped fresh — whether you're sending...
-
Snack Sticks & Sausages
Satisfy your cravings with our delicious selection of smoked beef sticks, summer...
